Memphis in May
|
|
1
2
3 4
5
6
7
8
9
10
2008
Scouting Trip
Back to Top |
|
The
World Championship Barbecue Cooking
Contest is held annually as part of the
Memphis in May International Festival.
The event is huge, with around 250 teams
from all over the country and a sprinkling of international teams as well.
During the three days of the competition, around 100,000 people come through
Tom Lee Park, and around $100,000 in prize money is at stake. The focus is
on pork, with three separate contests: one for "whole hog," one for "whole
shoulder," and one for "ribs." These teams are big, with tractor
trailer-sized smoking rigs and large investments in booths. Fortunately,
there is a fourth category, called Patio Porkers; these are smaller,
"semi-pro" teams who compete with each other on ribs.
We visited the WCBCC in 2008, and based
on our observations and encouragement from friends, decided to compete in
Patio Porkers in 2009. We got continuing positive feedback at events such as
our AT&T Pebble Beach Open House and our
William Shatner tutorial.
Wini and I attended a seminar where we
learned how the contest judges evaluate barbecue entries: appearance,
texture, taste, and overall impression.
Of course, we visited
Graceland on this trip, a
mandatory stop for all red-blooded Americans.
|

|
|
|
 |
It is impossible to compete without a
team. We were fortunate to have the "Marc Marasco Alumni Association" to
help us out. Aimee and Mike Aver went to college
with Marc. They now live outside of Nashville, and trucked their "Miss
Piggy" across the state for the event.
On the right is Jim Sciarra, who worked with Marc at
Kadiri and then later with me at Ravenflow. Jim flew in from San
Francisco to complete the team.
Mike was the chief assistant cook, while Jim took
photos and tended bar. Aimee helped out in dealing with the public.
Traeger Industries was kind enough to provide
sponsorship for our team. |
|
1 2
3 4
5
6
7
8
9
10
The 2009 Team
Rookie Season
Back to Top |
|
1
2 3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
2009 Observations and Results
Back to Top |
As this was our "rookie year," we made many rookie mistakes.
None of us had ever done this event before, and the team was a bit too
small. We competed in too many events; besides the mandatory rib event on
Saturday, we did a competition called People's Choice (not judged by an
expert panel) and a category called "Anything But." It turned out that these
other events distracted us from our main objective. Lesson learned. In the Patio Porker ribs event, we
finished 31st out of 44, scoring 446.2 points; the winning entry scored
480 points. Here is how we made out on the
detailed judges’ scorecard. In the first three categories, you are
scored in whole integers on a scale of 5 to 10. In the last category,
overall impression, you are scored in tenths on a scale of 5 to 10. In
each case, they drop the score of the lowest judge, which I have
indicated below by an asterisk (*).
| |
Judge 1 |
Judge 2 |
Judge 3 |
Judge 4 |
| Appearance |
9 |
8 |
7* |
10 |
| Taste |
9 |
8* |
9 |
10 |
| Tenderness |
9 |
8* |
9 |
10 |
| Overall Impression |
9.6 |
8* |
8.8 |
10 |
Note that extensive precautions are
taken to ensure that the judging is completely "blind."
On Sunday I visited another Memphis institution,
Sun Studios. |
|
 |
In 2010 we continued with Jim Sciarra as
co-pilot, and added Stan and Arlene Weinrich, who took over for the
Avers, who could not attend. Stan is a fraternity brother from the
Cooper Union days (1962-1966). Stan and Arlene resided in Memphis for
many years, although they were in the process of moving to the coast of
North Carolina at the time of the event. We would like to
thank Traeger dealer Pat Russell, of the BBQ Shop in Scottsboro Alabama,
for providing us with our competition grill this year. I guess all Miss Piggys
look alike!
Stan was our director of environmental engineering,
and Arlene helped out in a myriad of ways. As usual, Jim did a bang-up job, handling the bartending,
photographic, and all other miscellaneous duties with typical aplomb.
For lots of really great photos of the event, see
Jim's collection
here.
|
|
1
2
3 4
5
6
7
8
9
10
The 2010 Team
Sophomore Jinx?
Back to Top |
|
1
2
3 4 5
6
7
8
9
10
2010 Observations and Results
Back to Top |
| We were a lot more organized this year,
and having two participants with even one year of experience made a huge
difference. By concentrating on ribs only, we were able to improve our
performance. Stan and I had a wonderful time reminiscing about our
college days, and the weather was warm without much rain and mud.
Many of our fellow Patio Porkers were glad to see us
return. We began to appreciate the camaraderie of this group: On
Saturday it's a competition, but all week long there is an incredible
spirit of cooperation and friendliness. Some of it has to do with the
South, but more generally barbecue people just tend to be a touch more
relaxed. Perhaps maintaining a reasonable level of sobriety and not
getting too plastered before lunch helps. It is still the best three-day
party in the country.
We finished
16th out of 39 teams,
moving up 15 places; we are still awaiting the judges' detailed report
to see how. We did change our recipe from "sweet and sticky" to "dry and
spicy," improving our score from 446.2 (92.96%) to 459.7 (95.77%).
Needless to say, the competition at this World Championship level
continued to be fierce!
This Sunday I revisited Sun Studios and could have
done the tour better than our guide did it. |
|
|
 |
2011 saw Jim unable to join us, but the
Weinriches came all the way from Wilmington North Carolina. They were
joined by Jeff Wahl from Denver, and "Nice" Joe Greene from Carmel
California. As in previous years, the team arrived in staggered fashion
and left somewhat staggering as well. This year
the Mississippi decided to crest at Memphis at a height not seen since
1937. A week before the event, the entire festival was moved inland to
the parking lot complex surrounding the Liberty Bowl. That turned out to
be a good idea, as much of Tom Lee Park was under water the week of the
event.
This year everyone took photos, and the triage and
collation took a while. Most of the
photos are captioned, so they give you an idea of this year's
doings. |
|
1
2
3 4
5 6
7
8
9
10
The 2011 Team
The Year of the Great Flood
Back to Top |
|
1
2
3 4
5
6 7
8
9
10
2011
Special Event
Back to Top |
| During our set up on Wednesday morning,
we noticed Alton Brown of the Food Network riding around on a golf cart
with a camera crew. He seemed to enjoy the atmosphere in the Patio
Porker area, and Miss Piggy caught his eye. We encouraged him to come
back and spend some time with us. He did.
Unfortunately, the other half of our skeleton crew was off running
errands that morning, so we have only two photos taken by our next door
neighbor, Tom Clary, of The Count Bastie Porkestra. While they are not
great, they do provide evidence that we may someday pop up on an Alton
Brown segment on Memphis in May.
He was intrigued by the wood pellet technology. We
gave him the straight skinny. |
 |
 |
|
|
We had a wonderful time. We are now accepted as one of the
"repeat offender" teams, and share in the spirit of the event. Both Jeff and
Joe were quite taken by the good fellowship and general ambiance.
The competition results this year were disappointing. We finished
25th out of 37, worse than last year. Our score was 593.5 out of 640,
which indicates that the scoring system was different this year. The details
of the judges' evaluation follows; note the inconsistency between judge 2
and judge 3: judge 2 gives us 2 9's and a 10, with an overall of 9.9,
whereas judge 3 gives us 2 10's and a 9, but only 9.5 overall. Go figure!
| |
Judge 1 |
Judge 2 |
Judge 3 |
Judge 4 |
| Appearance |
9 |
9 |
10 |
9* |
| Taste |
9 |
10 |
9 |
9* |
| Tenderness |
9 |
9 |
10 |
9* |
| Overall Impression |
9.1 |
9.9 |
9.5 |
9* |
|
1
2
3 4
5
6
7 8
9
10
2011
Observations and Results
Back to Top |
|
1
2
3 4
5
6
7
8 910
2012
Back to Top |

From the left: Joe Greene,
Barbecue Joe, Stan Weinrich, Arlene Weinrich. Note the new tee shirts,
compliments of Arlene.
We finished 15th out of 43,
our best finish to date.
Here is the judges' report. As usual,
the lowest score, which is dropped, is indicated by an asterisk (*).
| |
Judge 1 |
Judge 2 |
Judge 3 |
Judge 4 |
| Appearance |
9* |
10 |
10 |
10 |
| Taste |
9* |
9 |
10 |
9 |
| Tenderness |
9* |
10 |
9 |
10 |
| Overall Impression |
9.8 |
9.6* |
9.7 |
9.7 |
|
|
Here are the cumulative results of four years of competition.
| |
2009 |
2010 |
2011 |
2012 |
|
Ranking |
31 / 44 |
16 / 39 |
25 / 37 |
15 / 43 |
|
Teams we finished ahead of |
13 |
23 |
12 |
28 |
|
Ranking by percentage (lower is better) |
70% |
41% |
68% |
35% |
|
Score |
446.2 / 480 |
459.7 / 480 |
593.5 / 640 |
607.4 / 633.1 |
|
Score as a percentage of winner |
93.0% |
95.8% |
92.7% |
95.9% |
|
A pattern emerges: If you garner around
93% of the points of the winner, you will finish with a ranking no better
than the twenties. To break through to the top twenty, you need about 96% of
the winner's total. To crack the top ten, you needed 97% of the winner's
point total this year. So we are close; it looks as though one more percent
will get us into the coveted top 10. This is probably a matter of converting
one non-dropped 9 to a 10.
|
1
2
3 4
5
6
7
8
910
Year by Year Comparison
Back to Top |
|
Back to Top |
Click here to e-mail Barbecue Joe on the subject of the Memphis in May |
Back to Barbecue Joe |